Right before Halloween I received a unexpectant phone call from Sean. Yes, you are reading this correctly. Thee Sean: who I thought I was madly deeply in love with only to be crushed by the reality of our relationship and his narcissist ways.....that one.
Since cutting off all ties with Sean I have not thought about him much which I know seems impossible since he was such a huge part of my life 5 years ago. As you all know I loved the shit out of that toxic boy for reasons I don't think I'll ever fully understand. I think my grief had something to do with it along with my lack of experience romantically and perhaps my inability to set boundaries. I know that this sounds like I'm placing a huge chunk of the blame on myself but in reality I am aware that there were so many red flags about Sean that I just ignored because I mistook the blurred lines as evidence that he loved me.
I am a person who loves hard and while this is beneficial in many aspects of my life it comes with a price. My empathy often gets the best of me and I have loved people who were incapable of loving me back. This isn't easy to admit because I possess the knowledge to have healthy relationships yet I still find myself in certain patterns that deny me them. I recognize this with Sean and Kat and Matt and even Tim. While I have really great relationships with other friends and family there has always been that ONE person that I invest all of my attention to. This person is my Favorite Person and I bend my boundaries and make exceptions for them because of this pedestal I place them on. MY day to day can be very dependent on them in some facet because this person usually fulfills my desire to exist in a partnership that is co-dependent because I mistake it for belonging.
It has taken 34 years to get to the realization and even still I struggle with managing this knowledge and applying better boundaries so I do not give so much of my agency to one person. Right now that person is Tim and I can't help but note the similarities between him and my previous FP relationships. My mood can be highly dependent on his to the point where I am distraught when we have a falling out. When things are consistent and good between us I feel elated and whole. But when they are not I cannot function: my brain is simply hyper focused on "saving" us. I sacrifice and dedicate all of my time to him and boundaries have flown straight out the window.
On top of that Tim lives with Bipolar and his moods can be erratic and at best unpredictable. And I am not using the term bipolar disparagingly to mock his moodiness. Tim and I have talked at length about his diagnosis and how it impacts his life and relationships. He has outbursts of anger, depression and hyperactivity that are a whirlwind. He is easily triggered by reactions that can turn a normal conversation into a circus. But honestly that extreme seems very cyclical and follows a pattern that I, at least, have learned to catch before it's released into our world. For the most part our ability to communicate when we need space or if we are having an off day has resulted in a relationship that with building blocks of boundaries that are stabilizing the kinks. Quarantine has helped immensely because it has forced boundaries that otherwise would not be set and this perhaps is the main thing that has strengthened our friendship and hopefully has set a different course than the past ones.
There are times though where we both slip back into bad habits ( I have a covid thanksgiving tale for the ages) and it feels like all that work is for naught but I guess where Tim and the other FP's differ is that we have gotten better at communicating with each other and our relationship doesn't feel one-sided. With Sean he was absolute favorite person to be around but our relationship was one-sided and at times did not feel real. It embarrasses me a little to admit that how I felt and how I acted may not have aligned at all with how he felt or responded to me. This isn't to say our relationship did not exist OR that any aspect of it was fabricated but I recognize that how I tell our story will always favor my narrative. It's always going to be how I saw it and how I lived it because I only have my POV to rely on.
Journaling gives me a little security in my retelling of events because I tend to record entries immediately after something has occurred. And when Sean was in my life, I was constantly writing about him and everything going on. But there have been moments post Sean where I can't help but wonder if what occurred between us was real or exaggerated based on the evidence. While I felt deeply for him how he treated me did not match up to what occurred so that must mean that what occurred was somehow not real. It's almost like having two versions of the same story presented to you but there are pivotal differences that distort the narrative as a whole which makes you reimagine the plot.
When I first met Sean I didn't like him at all. He started right before I headed home during that summer my aunt kicked me out (about 3 months) and I recall thinking he was uninteresting. When I came back that Fall I was confused when he gave me a hug and welcomed me back to the bookstore because we only had a few conversations prior to me leaving. I remember being unimpressed by him and befriended a ton of other people soon after my return. And then there is just this big gap between him being a co-worker that I was cordial with to him being a person I thought I was in love with. I'm sure there are entries where this discovery is made but for the life of me I cannot physically bring the memory up where my crush began.
Regardless of this memory lapse the moment he became a crush and then a friend and then a friend/crush I was caught up in the infatuation. I thought he was so cool and so funny and so cute. At the time everyone warmed me that he was a jerk but my rose colored glasses were stapled to my head. Obviously there are so many Sean entries to reread that I don't need to replay our relationship ad nauseam in this and plus we all know how it ended. All I can say now is that we formed a relationship that would be become extremely toxic and unhealthy that I had no choice but to cut it off for my own sanity.
Now that 5 years have passed I can look back on my relationship with Sean and realize it was never a romantic one. I liked him (a lot) and I romanticized the idea of him ( a lot) but we were never romantically involved. There have been many moments post Sean where I wonder what our relationship must have looked like without the filter I placed on it. I wonder if I was this clingy, naïve girl who imagined a relationship with a boy that never had an interest in her. And this isn't to say that I am a unreliable narrative but I did get so caught up in my feelings and lack of experience that I mistook a lot of things with Sean as romance when it was really manipulation (on his part) and eagerness to be loved (on my own).
He definitely took advantage of my feelings and he liked the attention I gave him but there was never anything genuine about how he felt for me based on how he treated me. Everything Sean did indicated that I was not a person he respected or cared about sincerely. I spent more time trying to convince Sean I was worthy to be in his life that I failed to see how toxic he was for my own. It was embarrassing and degrading now that I can look back on the experience. And honestly this knowledge has made moving on from Sean easier than expected. I think it was soon after he sent me a FB message telling me he was in town (almost 5 years ago to the date) and then ignored me while he was here that sent me over the edge. It always felt like he was dangling this unrealistic possibility in front of me only to pull it back when it was time to show face.
So I moved on because I wanted to and because I had to. And once I made that decision everything else just fell into place, like Tetris maybe, but in place. I got a new job and apartment, I got a car, I made new friends, I started to actually date people and have romantic relationships that were not just crushes. The last bit is probably what really confirmed how unreal my relationship with Sean was. Suddenly there was sex and love and desire which adds a whole new component to being with someone. There was learning to communicate my wants and needs as to not be taken advantage of. There was a little bit of heartbreak followed by boozy wine nights recuperating but the realness of it all was such a clear break from whatever it was that I thought I had with Sean.
And not having Sean in my life has been great! And not in the "new me, who this" way. It feels more like relief that I am no longer lying to myself about how much (or little) he cared for me. So, needless to say when I got this random text a few months ago from a person named "Sean" I initially didn't even register that it was him. It was before the election so I was getting a lot of "are you voting" texts and I just assumed it was someone trying to make sure I was registered. It was only after he responded back "Bookstore Sean, Navy Sean" that I put two and two together and the shock of the situation was overwhelming at best. He then said an introverts dreaded phrase "we need to talk. are you free"
A part of me wanted to put the chapter so far beyond me and just block his new number but the curious part of me was kind of scared by what he needed to talk about. For some reason I assumed he wanted to chastise me for idolizing a relationship that didn't exist. It was the first thought that flew through my head. I was like "huh, did I say something about Sean and I's relationship 5 years ago that got back to him and now he is pissed!" I still regularly talk to his cousin (a good friend) and there are a handful of people from the bookstore who I remain in contact with. So this wasn't a complete and out of pocket response. Not that I went around telling anyone that me and Sean were together but I definitely had conversations about how fucked up our friendship was and a few choice words about his relationship with his actual GF.
So when he said we needed to talk my immediate thought was "oh noes! He wants to verify my sneaking suspicion that I was wrong" that my version of the truth was so far fetched and nonsensical that now he needed to air his grievances 5 years later. So I called him and trust me I am shaking my head as much as you are at this fact. 5 years later and I picked up the damn phone when I should have hit that block button and kept it moving. I don't think either of us said anything for a solid two minutes. There was this blanket of silence and I thought one of us was having a bad connection. Then we both blurted out hellos just to make sure the other person was on the line.
Before I could even ask him what was so important that he needed to have this discussion out of the blue he said "I need to apologize to you". My heart stopped. Of all the things I thought he was going to say on the phone, an apology 5 years in the making was not one of them. Right after I cut ties with Sean there were so many nights where I imagined what words I wanted to hear from him to make up for all the things that went wrong. Of course these words involved "i'm sorry", "i fucked up" "i didn't know how to treat you" "you were lovely and amazing and I was the worst". But I never thought I would actually hear it from him. Ever.
He repeated it again "I owe you an apology" and then proceeded to go into the longest apology I have ever received in my 34 years. He said he was recently home to clear out his old room and found this journal I gifted him before he joined the Navy. I have no recollection of this journal but love notes are my thing so I am not surprised I penned him something. I think I started a journal for him around Christmas with just random entries from good days between us. This is the only thing i can think he stumbled upon at his parents and he said reading it 5 years later made him realize how awful he was. I shit you not. I was kind of perplexed and relieved. Relieved because HOLY SHIT I knew i was a reliable ass narrator despite my exploited feelings for the boy. I knew that I was good to him and kind and loving when I did not have to be. I knew this and he knew this and still proceeded to treat me like garbage.
He didn't really have an excuse as to why he was so awful and I didn't ask him. He did say being in the Navy, getting married and being far away from friends and family has altered him a lot. That age and maturity has caught up to him and he realizes that he was a dick to a lot of people; not just to me. He did reiterate that he was to blame and at fault for everything and that I was owed an apology even if I did not want to accept it. As I sat there listening to words I was grateful that he apologized but also surprisingly so over that time in my life that hearing the words only provided comfort to the girl I was back then. Up until 20 minutes prior, he was a person I rarely thought about and whose apology I stopped waiting for. In all honesty our friendship meant something at that time in my life and helped me out tremendously when it wasn't completely toxic. But I think we were two people who couldn't find the balance that needed to exist for being actual friends. I liked him way too much but was afraid to admit my feelings and I can't speak for him but I imagine their were complex feelings to contend with.
He asked me if I wanted to tell him off (which was bizarre) or curse him out for being such a shitty person in the past and I can tell this was what he needed as some form of penance. But I couldn't do it and I told him this. I told him that I was glad he reached out and was grateful for the apology but that I made peace with our relationship years ago by moving on. I told him that there was no need to yell or scream at him because the consequence of his behavior was that we were never going to be friends even with the apology. There was no way I was going to allow him in my life ever again. That he had every opportunity to save our friendship and instead he picked his ego. So there was no need for me to rail on his personality or character and that I think him having to live with the knowledge his actions alone resulted in us never being able to have a friendship was more than often pain. I also told him that the apology was something that would have been monumental years ago but that I am in such a different and better place in my life it just didn't feel necessary (I did also brag a little about the boss ass things that have occurred in my life. but only briefly).
I have always known (secretly) that I was not to blame for Sean. I attracted a person with bad intentions and stuck around because I was convinced my kindness would change him. I was convinced if I loved him harder he would find a way to love me. Of course this did not and does not occur and where Sean felt the need to apologize to me for this I already apologize to myself for putting up with the behavior for so long. 5 years ago I made peace with the person who get swept up into another person so much she forgot who she was and that she deserved so much more.
I ended the conversation soon after and he said he would leave the line of communication up to me. I told him there was no need for that and that after this call we'd remain on radio silence because while I accept his apology we would never be friends because of who he was. A phone call was not going to undo all the damage his actions caused when he was in my life. And just like that it was over. The call was pleasant, he seemed really sincere but I know this is not a friendship I want to rekindle. So, I blocked his number and am adding "call from Sean" to the 2020 events I did not see coming.